Showrunner Robert Doherty put that to bed before the show even came out, telling Digital Spy:
There aren’t any “catching her in a towel” moments and, the one moment we see her get dressed on screen, she does so under a sheet.When it was announced that Elementary‘sversion of Watson would be a woman, most people assumed that meant they would eventually get together romantically. While Irene Adler in Sherlock was introduced naked, Elementary seems to go out of its way not to sexualize Joan. Joan is a woman, but the show never frames her as a sex object. The most obvious example of diversity is the fact that they gender-bent Watson into not only a woman but a woman of color played by the amazing Lucy Liu. In season 2, we are introduced to their version of Irene Adler, who is a dominatrix lesbian who also falls for Sherlock.Įlementary, on the other hand, decided to go in another direction. The second episode of Sherlock delved into some nasty Asian stereotypes. While it can be explained away as two shows being made in two different cultures, the truth of the matter is that diversity in television matters. It has lead to a more polarizing and interesting dynamic between the main characters and is one of the main reasons Elementary has managed to avoid becoming “just another CBS police procedural.” Diversity that doesn’t feel shoehorned in…
#Review sherlock holmes elementary nyt full#
The character development in the BBC version of the show don’t have time to focus that much on long-form storytelling or character arcs because they only have three 90-minute episodes, while Elementaryhas a full CBS season. Elementary uses its narrative time to develop Joan as a person in a way that Sherlocksimply doesn’t have the same time to do. Joan isn’t a soldier, but she is a doctor and it’s very easy to see her going back and doing that again if she wanted. John is also supposed to be a soldier, but does things such as carry a gun in the rim of his pants, which a real soldier would never do.
#Review sherlock holmes elementary nyt how to#
Sherlock takes advantage of Watson’s medical expertize often, whether it is asking for clarification on a certain type of anesthetic or Watson showing Holmes how to properly test if someone is in a coma. In the BBC version, Sherlock uses the fact that he has a doctor living with him to his advantage because he already knows everything. She is his equal but in very different ways and Elementarydoes not skirt around that.Įlementary also does not ignore the fact that Watson is, in fact, a doctor - or, in this case, a former surgeon. When Sherlock leaves after season 2, we come back in season 3 to find that Watson has been working with the New York City police on her own as a detective and has been doing a great job. Instead of following Sherlock around and being constantly amazed by his brilliance, Watson is just as good of a detective as Sherlock in her own way.
However, Elementary goes a different direction with it. The more modern adaptations of Holmes stories (the Guy Ritchie movies, House, and Sherlock) have been much better at painting Watson as a character with a personality. Watson is treated as Sherlock’s equal & uses her medical expertise…įor many years, whenever people would adapt Sherlock Holmes stories, they would make Watson a paper-thin straight man or a bumbling fool in order to make Holmes look smarter. The brief meeting between Sherlock and John in episode one of Sherlock is entertaining, but lacks that same emotional punch. The moment in season 1 when Sherlock finally admits that he needs Joan and would like to take her on as a partner is much more moving because it’s given time to grow. Joan is not there because she wants to be initially, she is there to do her job and only becomes Sherlock’s friend later on. Because this version of Watson is not a doctor anymore, but a sober companion in Sherlock’s life to help him through his addiction recovery, the dynamic is much different from any other form of the Holmes/Watson story. Because of this, the character development that the show has been able to produce feels much more organic.Įlementary‘s version of Holmes and Watson are not close friends right away, and it takes the better part of the first season for the two of them to truly click. Elementary, however, has the benefit of being on American television and has had four 24-episode seasons. Since the three seasons were more like three movies instead of an overarching story, it has made character development much harder. (Remember, Sherlockis technically a British-American co-production, though with definitely more creative control on the other side of the pond.) However, the show became notorious right away as several years would pass between the three seasons.
Long-form storytelling that leads to richer character development…īBC’s Sherlock decided to do three 90-minute episodes instead of a 12 or 13-episode season like some shows on the BBC, or many shows in the United States.
0 kommentar(er)
